Life began in water, an idea we seem to have understood long before science explained evolution. Why else did fish symbolize fertility in so many ancient cultures, from Egypt to the Celts, Indians, Mesopotamians, Burmese, Persians and Slavs?

Through the centuries – beginning more than 14,000 years ago - fish have carried sacred meanings when they appeared in visual art. A fish scratched in the ground was an early Christian symbol and became a symbol of baptism, our immersion in water.

But the image of a fish can tell a very different story.

In 1557, a print in the style of Pieter Bruegel the Elder, for example, made a political point. It illustrated an ancient Latin proverb, “The Big Fish Eat the Little Fish,” demonstrating how the powerful rule society.

Historical painting of large fish eating smaller fish
The Big Fish Eat the Little Fish, Pieter Brueghel the Elder, 1557

Not long after, Guiseppe Arcimboldo, sometimes called the great-grandfather of surrealism, gave us a haunting allegory about the power of “Water” in a face made up of fish.

Historical painting of person compromised of various sea creatures
Water, Giuseppe Arcimboldo, 1566

Fish appeared in the first still-life paintings, in compositions of richly laden tables demonstrating abundance. At the time, the Catholic church and custom insisted on meatless days as often as three days a week, so fish was frequently on the menu.

Fish pictured as food is generally raw, probably because the colors are more vivid and varied than in a cooked fish. An example from the early 17th century comes from Flemish still-life specialist Clara Peeters, whose depictions of feasts sometimes suggested domestic drama –will the housecat take a bite?

Historical painting of cat and fish
A Still Life with Carp in Ceramic Colander, Clara Peeters, circa 1620

Another example is from Vincent Van Gogh, whose 1886 “Still Life with Mackerel, Lemon and Tomato” is the image at the top of this article.

Allegory seems always lurking in the background even in modern depictions of fish. For example, when an enormous fish soars above three men in a canoe, in Winslow Homer’s 1895 classic “A good pool, Sagueney River” the scene is reminiscent of Moby Dick, the story of a man obsessed with taking revenge against an immense whale.

Historical painting of fishermen in boat on rough seas and large fish above the water
A Good Pool, Saguenay River, Winslow Homer, 1895

In Paul Klee’s “The Golden Fish,” painted in 1925, the body of the fish contains scratchy shapes that suggest the early Christian symbol and the overall fish is greatly simplified, as if symbolic. Have we come full circle?   

Historical painting of yellow fish on dark background
The Golden Fish, Paul Klee, 1925

Symbolism aside, fish are simply beautiful in their own essence. We see this in the most realistic renderings of all, created with a technique that began in Japan in the mid-1800s known as gyotaku: “gyo” is “fish” and “taku” means “rubbing.” Anglers kept rice paper, ink, and brushes on their boats so that they could make ink renderings of their fresh catch, brag about its size and perhaps marvel at its splendor.

Today, artists sometimes put ink on a fish body and press silk or rice paper on top, or they might put paper on the body and then apply the ink. They then paint in the eyes and other details to create stunning underwater worlds.

Example of Japanese goyataku, a fish rubbing on rice paper
Example of goyataku, artist unknown

Inhabitants of a world obscure and mysterious to us, yet the one in which our distant ancestors were born, often beautiful, essential to human thriving and believed a locus of miracles, fish are to the artist – as to all of us - many glorious things at once.

May we continue to appreciate them in their many-splendored beauty! 

 

Sources:

Coffman, E. What is the origin of the Christian FISH SYMBOL? Christianity Today.   https://www.christianitytoday.com/history/2008/august/what-is-origin-of-christian-fish-symbol.html  Published August 8, 2008.

Nastyuk, E. The fish in art. https://arthive.com/encyclopedia/30~The_fish_in_art. Published April 22, 2014.

Still Life with fish, a candle, artichokes, crab and prawns - The Collection. (n.d.). Retrieved January 31, 2021, from https://www.museodelprado.es/en/the-collection/art-work/still-life-with-fish-a-candle-artichokes-crab-and/075026b9-f6d7-4c7e-8f07-15f4f74e75b8

Zhang, J. Gyotaku: The Traditional Japanese Art of Painting Marine Life with Actual Fish. https://mymodernmet.com/heather-fortner-gyotaku/  Published September 2, 2015.