Ad
Get special offers, recipes, health news, PLUS our FREE seafood cooking guide!
Got it, thanks! Click here for your FREE seafood cooking guide & recipes e-booklet.
Food, Health, and Eco-news
Breast Cancer Risk Raised by too Much Red Meat
11/16/2006
First study to focus on younger pre-menopausal women finds anincreased risk for hormone receptor-positive breast tumors
by Craig Weatherby


The results of an innovative study affirm the dangers of excessive enjoyment of red meat. While they don't mean that women can't eat red meat safely, these findings indicate that it may make sense to practice moderation and stick to grass-fed beef.

The authors of the study
led by Harvard's Eunyoung Cho, Sc.D. (pictured at left)noted that while high red meat intake is considered conducive to breast cancer, none of the previous studies included substantial numbers of young, pre-menopausal women.

Key Points
  • Rates of hormone receptor-positive breast tumors are rising in the U.S.
  • Pre-menopausal women's risk of hormone receptor-positive cancer was twice as high if they ate more than one and one-half servings of red meat a day, compared with those who ate three or fewer servings per week.
  • Red meat consumption did not affect their risk of breast cancer overall or hormone-receptor-negative cancers.
  • “Hormone receptor-positive” tumors in which women's sex hormones (estrogen and progesterone) bind to receptor proteins on the surfaces of the tumor cells.
  • “Hormone receptor-negative” tumors in which this does not occur.
This data gap explains why, when Dr. Cho's group set out to look for any links between red meat consumption and breast cancer, they focused on pre- menopausal women: specifically, 90,659 members of the Nurses' Health Study II whose average age was 36 at the outset of the study.

In addition, the Boston-based team were looking for any differences in risk between the two major types of breast cancer:

As they said, “The association between red meat intake and breast cancer is unclear, but most studies have assessed diet in midlife or later. Although breast tumors differ clinically and biologically by hormone receptor status, few epidemiologic studies of diet have made this distinction.”

Any difference in the degree of breast cancer risk posed by high red meat intake is of special interest because, as the Boston team wrote, “… the incidence of hormone receptor-positive tumors has been increasing in the United States, especially among middle-aged women.”

Dr. Cho and her colleagues—who included legendary Harvard nutrition researcher Walter C. Willett, M.D.--followed the women from 1991 through 2003.

The women completed an initial diet questionnaire in 1989, and responded to subsequent food intake surveys in 1991, 1995 and 1999.

Every two years they reported whether or not they had developed breast cancer. Any reported cases were confirmed through hospital records and pathology reports.

Only pre-menopausal women never diagnosed with cancer were included in the data, and any who experienced menopause or an ovariectomy during the 12 years of the study were not.

By the end of the study, the women reporting the highest red meat intake were not at significantly greater risk for breast cancer overall or for hormone-receptor-negative cancers, but did show an increased risk of hormone receptor-positive cancer.

In fact, the risk of hormone receptor-positive cancer was twice as high among women who ate more than one and one-half servings of red meat a day, compared with those who ate three or fewer servings per week.

Why would red meat cause hormone receptor-positive breast cancer? The researchers noted three reasons:
  • Cooked or processed red meats contain known cancer-causing compounds that increase mammary tumors in animals and are suspected of causing breast cancer in humans.
  • Cattle in the United States are treated with hormones to promote growth, which could influence breast cancer risk.
  • The form in which iron occurs in red meat may promote tumors.
It's probably safer to stick to certified grass-fed beef, whose fat profile leans heavily toward anti-cancer omega-3s, with many fewer cancer-fueling omega-6 fats than occur in standard, grain-fed beef.


Source
  • Cho E, Chen WY, Hunter DJ et al. Red Meat Intake and Risk of Breast Cancer Among Premenopausal Women. Arch Intern Med. 2006;166:2253-2259.

WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS ARE SAYING:
quote-icon
I would not buy my fish from anywhere but Vital Choice…I’m so happy to have a source for great tasting, healthy fish.
quote-icon
WHAT HEALTH & NUTRITION EXPERTS ARE SAYING:
quote-icon
Vitalchoice.com is my favorite source for wild Alaskan salmon, sablefish, sardines, and other fish rich in omega-3s... I can't tell you how many messages I get from people thanking me for recommending Vital Choice.
quote-icon
WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS ARE SAYING:
quote-icon
Simply put Vital Choice offers the best seafood and related products available. We have always recommended Vital Choice to clients, friends, and family. As health practitioners we value the sustainable practices and trust this company implicitly!
quote-icon
WHAT THE MEDIA IS SAYING:

quote-icon We’ve done the work for you to find the healthiest meat products on the market. quote-icon

WHAT HEALTH & NUTRITION EXPERTS ARE SAYING:
quote-icon
Unlike anything you've seen from the grocery store…I recommend Vital Choice—my personal favorite for delicious, fresh, healthy, and completely safe canned tuna and salmon.
quote-icon
WHAT THE MEDIA IS SAYING:
quote-icon
Vital Box captures the fresh-caught quality of succulent, sustainably harvested Alaskan salmon and northwest Pacific seafood by cleaning and flash-freezing it within hours of harvest.
quote-icon
WHAT HEALTH & NUTRITION EXPERTS ARE SAYING:
quote-icon
I love the stellar quality of Vital Choice salmon! I've been recommending Vital Choice Seafood for many years now.
quote-icon
WHAT OUR CUSTOMERS ARE SAYING:
quote-icon
Vital choice has never disappointed. Love every item I get... since eating your food, my hair, skin, and energy revitalized from clean fish and meats… it’s ALL great. Never a problem with the food arriving in great condition.
quote-icon
WHAT THE MEDIA IS SAYING:

quote-icon The Best Places To Buy Seafood Online, Including Fresh And Frozen Fish quote-icon 

Find out what others are saying about Vital Choice Ad