Product Reviews

Wild Sardines in Organic Extra Virgin Organic Olive Oil 4-3/8 oz

Write your own review | Return to product details >>

Average Ratings: 5


Rate this product:

"Sardines in Organic EVOO"

Katherine on 4/10/2014 3:22:55 AM


Review: Excellent tasting sardines and the absolute best I have ever tasted.

"Sardines in Organic Olive Oil"

Anthony on 4/4/2014 5:14:48 AM


Review: Excellent sardines, best canned I've ever had.

"2nd Best"

Eric Evans on 10/28/2012 5:28:54 PM


Review: These sardines have great texture and flavor. For me, they are second only to the Vital Choice spiced sardines, which are my favorite, and far superior to sardines available in grocery stores.

"Absolutely, no-close-second, the BEST sardines I've ever eaten"

Joy Gadaway on 5/9/2011 7:57:01 PM


Review: Wonderful video! I've enjoyed Vital Choice sardines and in fact have given them as Christmas presents! They are absolutely, no-close-second, the BEST sardines I've ever eaten. I am very grateful for this lovely gift from the sea and for the care that is taken every step of the way.

"Best sardines but Omega 3 numbers flawed"

glenn on 4/28/2011 10:37:44 AM



These are the best canned Sardines I have ever tasted, and I have purchased them many times from Vital Choice and will continue to do so, but, the Omega 3 content is highly suspect. If you look at the Sardines in water it says they have a total of 3398mg of Omega 3's per can.(1699mgx2=3398mg).The ones in olive oil have 5306mg per can. (2653mgx2=5306mg). The only difference in the ones with olive oil is the addition of olive oil. There is only a trace of Omega 3's in olive oil. Only a trace, and they are saying that there is an additional 1908mg in the ones with olive oil. Also they are saying that there is an additional 14% Calcium in the olive oil Sardines. Again, there's no Calcium in olive oil. I doubt that there is even 3398mg of Omega 3 in the Sardines with water. I have written to Vital Choice on this but they didn't respond [WE DID RESPOND ... SEE BELOW]. They should release their laboratory numbers. Still awesome sardines though.
The omega-3 figures for our water- and oil-packed sardines come from validated laboratory tests, which we can provide upon request.
The numbers suggest that the omega-3s in sardines leach into surrounding water more than into surrounding olive oil. This is counterintutive, but we are confident of the accuracy of our lab results because they dovetail with other numbers we've seen. 
The explanation for the higher calcium content in the oil-packed fish is also a function of the differing interactions between the calcium in the fish and the surrounding oil or water, with water apparently leaching more calcium from the fish than olive oil does.

1 2

Write your own review

Rate this product:


For orders, questions, or assistance call 800-608-4825 any day or time. © 2014 Vital Choice Wild Seafood & Organics, Inc. All Rights Reserved